Two Sundays ago my RA, AC tweeted me concerning this article which had everybody upset. I myself could not believe what I was reading. In the end I was led to write a response. Little did I know that it would be featured as a column and I'd be guest columnist. Thanks a mil to the Gleaner Company and my frennie Sarah Bailey who brought it to my attention.
To see my published response click HERE.
Here is my full response (BE WARNED: IT IS LONG):
THE EDITOR Sir:
As a female aspiring to make a worthy contribution to the Jamaican society, I found yesterday's article entitled, 'Are Women Natural Leaders' quite disheartening. I must however thank the writer for making his views known. His response to the proposal for gender equality has highlighted the fact that there are still men and women out there who believe women are not capable of leading. I must also point out that while he made some noteworthy points, I am led to presume that his arguments were more about blaming women for ''dysfunctional families, the degradation of societal mores...perversions'' and not what the implementation of a gender equality quota would entail.
The Government of Jamaica proposed to use temporary special measures such as quotas to endorse gender equality as a means of fulfilling it's obligations under CEDAW. The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) is an international agreement that the Government made with other countries to protect women from discrimination in its various forms. The Government signed the agreement on September 3, 1981 and it came into effect on October 19, 1984. The government has endorsed the need for quotas as outlined in the National Policy on Gender Equality. I say this to point out that gender equality is nothing new to the Jamaican society.
Quoting the 51% Coalition (the organization whose members successful lobby for maternity leave in Jamaica), "Quotas which lead to increased numbers of women in decision-making and to the inclusion of gender perspectives in national policy are critical." I believe that we have some excellent male leaders. I also believe that a qualified woman in Parliament is better able to represent my views especially on issues which affect women in a different way than they affect men.
The naysayers are quick to point out that quotas are against the principle of equal opportunity for all, since women are given preference over men. They will also argue that quotas imply that politicians are elected because of their gender, not because of their qualifications and that more qualified candidates are pushed aside. In rebutting these arguments it must be said that the proposal is not to have women take over the positions of men but to allow women the same opportunities to serve their country in decision-making positions. I must also point to the fact that there exists a quota in our GSAT system which is in favour of male students. The writer was quick to point out that women have been able to assume leadership roles outside of the home. According to him this is based on academic achievement and these women are unable to effectively balance family life and careers.
In 2010, Professor Keith Laws, a psychologist at the University of Hertfordshire, led a research on whether women are better at multitasking than men. He and his team found that women are able to take on different duties at the same time and produce excellent results. Scientists believe that the results show that females are better able to reflect upon a problem, while continuing to juggle their other commitments, than men.
Quotas for women do not discriminate, instead they compensate for actual barriers that prevent women from their fair share of the decision-making seats. Women have a right as citizens to equal representation and women's experiences are needed in political, business and all areas of life. Women are just as qualified as men but women's qualifications are downgraded and minimized in a male-dominated political system. If women are represented in the legislature, they can help remove some of the structural barriers that prevent women from being elected. Also they are better able to advocate on behave of the women of Jamaica.
In closing his argument the writer stated, "A female should be entitled to an organisational position only if the best man for the job is a woman. And her gender should not be one of the qualifications." I find this statement to be quite misleading. Also, the assumptions which will arise from such a statement will be nothing more than the opinions of the misinformed. Having listened to the Senator and members of the 51% Coalition outline what they wish to achieve, I was not led to conclude that the aim is to get women into these positions based on their gender. Having served this year as the Elect Her: UWI Women Win Student Liaison, Program Assistant to the Mary Seacole Hall Leadership Academy and Peer Leader of the UWI Leads and last year serving on a subcommittee of the University's Guild of Students and a number of other student-led committees, I know for a fact that women are qualified for these positions and do not need hand outs to succeed in whatever they do. All we need is the opportunity to prove that we are capable.
According to the 51% Coalition, "Gender quota legislation would hold the Jamaican government to gender equality commitments it has already made, and that appear unlikely to be realized in the absence of targeted affirmative action." Through the Nation in Vision 2030 the government has explicitly committed to implementing governance structures and processes which reflect gender equality in representation and decision-making (Vision 2030 Gender Sector Plan, July 2009/June 2010, p.71).
After seeing yesterday's article my colleague also pointed out that the photograph which accompanied the writer's views did the Senator no favours. Indeed, it made her out to be just what the writer described as, "female doggish behaviour" which according to him is the "resultant from the concept of gender equality." How we are portrayed by the media is another ongoing battle for women. However, I'll leave that argument for another letter. Women's voices and experiences are needed to provide oversight and policy direction in the country to promote women's gender interest, including the rights of our children and families.
Last Saturday, I had the privilege of sitting in the same room with females parliamentarians and other female leaders from across the Americas at the Executive Meeting of the Network of Women Parliamentarians of the Americas and last year I attended the National Conference for College Women Student Leaders (NCCWSL)held in Washington DC. Both experiences pointed out that this fight for gender equality is not unique to the Jamaican society. Our counterparts across the world are fighting for gender equality, for women to have the right to negotiate their pay, for women to be given equal opportunities and for women to make contributions to legislation in the areas of health care, sexual harassment, violence in the home, human trafficking and child labour. The lessons I've learned from the numerous leadership workshops, academies, training seminars, meetings and conferences have left me yearning to do more as a young Jamaican woman.
I encourage the writer to start his male-lobby organisation. I also stand in support of his statement, "The real man is fast becoming an endangered species." As a young twenty something looking forward to success in family life and career, I would really appreciate seeing more men like my father who are not threatened by the success of women but rather stand by her side as her equal. Men who have confidence in
"their manhood" could never be described as "spinelessness". Arguments for quota systems based on gender have no concern with males and what the writer dubs the "rediscover [of] their testicular fortitude."
I stand in support of the Senator and members of the 51% Coalition as I see the need for gender equality in Jamaica. I believe in giving men and women the same opportunities. I do not believe this country can run effectively without both sexes.
In closing I must once again thank the writer for expressing his views. Your piece has ignited the flames burning in women across Jamaica and will push them to work even harder for equality. This "feisty, emotionally charged and often combative" woman rests her case.
Shavell S. Skeel
Elect Her: UWI Women Win Student Liaison
NCCWSL 2013 Attendee
Mary Seacole Hall Leadership Academy Student Assistant
AAUW Member
3rd Year Student
Faculty of Law
The University of the West Indies